Why I gave up archaeology

The dream of archaeology starts with imagination. Ancient landscapes. Forgotten cities. Secrets buried just beneath the soil. I chased that dream with everything I had, leaving behind a steady career as a writer so I could finally uncover the past for myself. But dreams have a way of changing when you get close enough to touch them and mine unraveled far more quietly than I expected.

But after ten years mostly confined to an office, twiddling my thumbs and desperately trying to find something exciting in the career I’d spent thousands of pounds on and years of my life chasing, I knew something was wrong. Deep down, I knew it was time to admit defeat.

When I handed in my resignation for what would be my final archaeology job, I expected regret to hit me like a wave. It didn’t. What I felt instead was a strange mixture of sadness and relief. Sadness that I would no longer spend my days writing about Romans or Iron Age communities, weaving their lives into weekly reports. But as I sat alone in my flat afterwards, it was the relief that took over. The truth was simple: the career I imagined had never matched the reality.

What most archaeologists don’t tell you is that archaeology isn’t glamorous. It isn’t treasure hunts or life‑changing discoveries. It’s poor pay, long hours, being treated as easily replaceable. It’s years of scraping by and justifying the struggle because you’re passionate. You either do something you love and earn very little, or something you hate and earn comfortably. For years, I chose the former. I took the punch to the chin every time I was overlooked in favour of a male colleague, every time I was expected to work longer and harder just to be considered adequate.

I once pictured myself spending days in dusty libraries, pouring over ancient texts, or examining bones in a quiet lab. But then I met PhD students who spoke openly about the years of poverty, burnout, and mental decline they endured to finish their research. That was enough for me to choose a different path. I went into commercial archaeology instead.

Within a year, the disappointment set in. I was clocking into a nine‑to‑five, writing endless reports about artefacts found 140 metres from a development site, staring at financial spreadsheets instead of history. I felt disconnected from everything that had drawn me to archaeology in the first place. Was I even doing archaeology anymore? The only part I still enjoyed was the research, and that small spark kept me going for another six years.

Eventually, I laid down my figurative trowel for good. The constant comments about my relationship status, the patronising tone, the way certain men felt entitled to speak to me, it all piled up until I couldn’t pretend anymore. For months, I wondered if it was just the particular environment I was in, not the whole industry. But when I wrote my final report, I knew the truth. I didn’t care anymore. I didn’t care whether the Romans had settled there or whether an Iron Age hillfort stood nearby. I just wanted to leave.

So I did. I moved into a different career. And strangely, that’s when everything changed.

By stepping awaywhile still keeping one foot in the wider heritage world, I rediscovered the love I thought I’d lost. I started reading archaeology books again. I went to exhibitions. I gave lectures on prehistory whenever I could. I reconnected with old archaeology friends, chatting excitedly about new discoveries and new theories. I felt like that 22 archaeology student again, full of energy, curiosity, and wonder.

It was exactly the renewal I didn’t know I needed. Sometimes you don’t lose passion. Sometimes it just gets buried, waiting for you to find it again.

The Archaeologist’s Ikigai (生き甲斐)

Like many within the current isolation bubble (COVID-19 for time-travellers reading this) I have turned to more soul-searching ways to burn daylight. I often find myself browsing through the various books on my wishlist on Amazon, looking for something that might answer the nonsensical questions buzzing around my weary mind.

I finally managed to get around Tim Tamashiro’s book on How to Ikigai. There are many ways in which I strive for a fulfilling life but like most I have found myself stuck in a rut, feeling the opposite – unfulfilled bogged down by societal expectations and entrenched daily routines.

Ikigai (生き甲斐, pronounced [ikiɡai]) is a Japanese concept that means “a reason for being”.

A reason for being is not as simple as it seems, because like most things our Ikigai is intertwined with modern day society expectations – paying the rent, having a family and public perceptions on what it means to be “successful”. That’s the problem for millions of people: how can you feel fulfilled when you’re constantly weighed down by burdens such as financial responsibilities and built -in routines – all of which dominate our lives?

Well let’s break it down: there are four parts to Ikigai, which roughly translates to:

  1. What do you love?
  2. What are you good at?
  3. What does the World need?
  4. What do you get paid for?

For myself the answer for the first question comes quite easily: archaeology. But does doing what you love translate well into doing what you’re good at? This is where for a long time I dawdled on the concept of Ikigai. What does being good at archaeology truly mean? Does it mean I understand the patterns of human behaviors? Good knowledge of human history? Or am I really exceptional at digging holes?
Before I decided to become an archaeologist, I developed a talent for understanding the detail, which made my articles about Japan and history insanely popular when I freelanced as a journalist. My sense of belief and purpose however still remained on an individual level, despite spending a lot of my young adult life in a country (Japan) that focused on the collective rather than the individual. But most importantly my talents didn’t necessarily connect with my passion.

After years of studying and traversing the perils of academia I soon realised that scholarly archaeology was nothing more than fanciful projects appealing for funding and getting lost in the bibliography of quite dull publications. For many of us archaeology is still entrenched in layers of jargon and dryness. While museums and television programmes allowed for the public to view archaeology from an outsider’s perspective the feeling of inadequacy still permeates people’s understanding – the leave it to the experts sentiment is felt throughout “amateur” spheres and casual participants. Is archaeology delegated to academic research in ill-forgotten journals? Yes, but it is also so much more, it’s about understanding our ancestors’ story. A story which in theory should be available to everyone.

The story is out there within the dusty books lying on library shelves, the unpublished papers saved on hard drives, and the bones left in boxes stored in forgotten archives. Our Ikigai is clear: the world needs for people to feel connected with their past. We need people to connect to their past just as much as they connect with their present and future. For the longest time in my life I was paid to write, to make the mundane interesting and informative, when I gave it up to pursue my passion for the human past I thought no more of connecting with audiences through the medium of word.

But the medium of word is flexible, it’s multifaceted, while many academics frown upon the flowery and indulgent prose littered in popular non-fiction it’s a tool, a weapon against the tedious monotone of academic writing. People might walk around the ruins of a fallen civilization taking in the awe and other-worldliness, but that’s no use if the visitors don’t understand it’s significance.

If archaeologists really care about the past and what it means then their ikigai needs to be conveying the story to the masses in every medium possible through art, film, prose, movies and virtual experiences like video-games. Without making it a niche experience or laughing it off as an amateurish hobby. We can’t all experience archaeology through the 10-year excavation process, but we can make sure that experiences are accessible and inclusive. Why can’t video games, movies, TV shows provide a sense of interaction with the past that many kids might not otherwise have?

We can try to align these conscience efforts with meaningful actions that will fulfill our lives, but we can’t do it on an individual level it has to be done as a collective, together as archaeologists we can encompass all the properties of Ikigai to tell a story not fully told.

Archaeology as my identity

Despite years of studying, months in a muddy field, and endless days counting fragments of bones in a lab, I was still not a professional archaeologist. And as I mingled with new acquaintances or bumped into old school friends I constantly referred to myself as an archaeologist. I felt like I was telling some insidious lie, and have perpetuated it throughout the last two years. I had tried and tried like most graduates to get a job within the heritage industry that paid more than just above minimum wage. If I complained,  I kept hearing those words that archaeologists hate: “you do it because you love it” as if love alone could pay the rising interest on my credit card bills. But then I realised; that archaeology was more than just a way of paying the bills it was how I came to view the world; it had become my religion.

Archaeology goes beyond interpreting the material culture of the past, there is something about studying archaeology that changes your way of thinking in current society. You start to assess everything around you as though you were seeing it from the future, the questions of what, how and most importantly why become everyday occurrences. The need to constantly assess human behaviour becomes part of everyday life. It becomes just another cognitive function.

When I worked as an office worker, I constantly referred to myself as an archaeologist. This may be as some have pointed out as a form of self-validation, but to me it was true. I was never going to be the world’s best admin assistant, I was going to discover something no one had ever seen before, because archaeology was and always has been my end goal. Like those “writers” starting their first novel at a cafe, exchanging ideas with fellow writers. It’s the same premise, when you see another archaeologist drool over a piece of flint, or another jump for joy over a worked deer antler – the only bone that has come out of a tonne of soil – you start to understand what archaeology means, not just to our understanding of the past but to the people who do it.

In a modern world so fast and self-involved, I think we all feel a little disconnected from the past. My way of thinking has been shaped by my experience on the field, by my life counting bones, by the conversation post-lecture. Archaeology becomes more than just what we interpret about history but how it’s directly relevant to us.